Best Answer - Chosen by Asker
If, as you say, this unit is about 5 years old, I have to think the temp. setting has been working where it is for some time, unless someone has changed it recently. Even then, the unit should fire up for longer than just a few minutes. It takes longer than that to heat the volume of water that would have cooled to where it would call for heat. In a gas fired water heater there are very few working parts, just a pilot light and burner and the gas valve. If it's lighting and burning at all, we know those two parts are working ok, which leaves the valve itself. A couple of the other folks have mentioned warranties, but for a unit this old, the parts warranty, which is one year on everything up to a start up of 9 years, would make this out of warranty I suspect. This valve is usually in the $170 - $225 range and you need a very good hardware or major appliance parts company to get one for you. It's can be difficult to remove, only because you need a very large pipe wrench. You'd need to drain the water from the tank, shut down the gas, remove all the small pipes underneath, carefully, then unscrew the valve from the tank. Replace in reverse and you should be good .
Source(s):
35 + years of water heater installations and repairs
- Asker's Rating:

- Asker's Comment:
- thanks ! * sigh * should just get a new one