lovecraft, tolkien, or salinger, which is the better writer?
- PrinceLv 54 weeks ago
Not Salinger. Salinger sucked as a writer. Salinger sucked so badly between floors that you get off the elevator with the sickly green queasy kind of feeling you get from a stomach full of elevator man juice. Like escaping forced masturbation in a dormitory to getting your hair ruffled on your teacher's sofa in the City. Bad. So it's between Lovecraft and Tolkien and there's no comparison because Tolkien was academic and erudite;whereas, Lovecraft is popular pulp fiction.
- JohnLv 51 month ago
Tolkien was (in same year as Robert Frost) nominated for a Nobel Prize for Literature.
Lovecraft is very niche and Salinger lacks depth.
I would also say the millions of sales, (pre the films) through people liking the story and it selling by word of mouth, plus the fact of character development in the Hobbit and sheer neat prose puts Tolkien ahead.
- curtisports2Lv 71 month ago
Salinger is known for one book. I couldn't fathom Tolkien. Lovecraft by default.
- Elaine MLv 71 month ago
Better in what way? Lovecraft was writing their books pre-1940, the writing style was very different. Salinger only wrote one book, never did another. Tolkien wrote in the 1960's, again it's different than the writing in the past 40 years.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- ElaineLv 71 month ago
It depends on your criteria for "better writer". Are you thinking of author's writing style, character and plot development, comparison to other authors in the same genre, etc?
- magix151Lv 71 month ago
I'm partial to tolkien.
- Anonymous1 month ago
Depends what you are interested in. Being English I prefer Tolkien.
There is only so much teenage angst one can take for chrissakes.
- AmberLv 51 month ago
Salinger I think.
- AndrewLv 71 month ago
None is any better than the others because they're all dead. When he was alive, Salinger was the best of the three.