e^t, where t is time. Both the exponential function and its argument must be dimensionless. ?

Clearly the function has a "t" as a unit of time. How can this equation be valid. Can anyone help me understand this paradox?

3 Answers

  • Vaman
    Lv 7
    1 month ago

    This equation is not valid. The term in the exponent shoud be dimensionless. You need e^(wt) or e^(t/T) type.

  • Dixon
    Lv 7
    1 month ago

    You are correct, raising to a power means the power must be just a number. Typically you will see t/τ where τ is some kind of "time constant" in the same units as t. So if t is in years and τ = 100 years, this would effectively give you e^(number of centuries) 

  • 1 month ago

    Yes, you're right.  Technically, it's not valid.  Generally, in physical sciences you'll find that a formula involving exponential growth in time has coefficients with units that cancel out or apply dimensionality as needed;  something of the form:

        f(t) = A e^(bt)

    The units of b will be such that bt is dimensionless, while the dimensions of A will be those expected for the function result.  The same is true for powers with a variable exponent or with a variable base and an irrational exponent, as well as for logarithms, trig functions and other special functions.

    Something similar also happens in polynomials, where an equation like

        f(t) = at^2 + bt + c

    ....had different dimensonality on each constant so that the terms all have the dimensionality required for the function result. 

    In math textbooks, though, dimensionality is often ignored--even in so-called "real world" problems. 

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.