Which Phyllis did you like? Michelle Stafford or Gina Tagnoni?

Answer 1

Gina was best imo

Answer 2

Michelle Stafford, she was alwyas my fave actress.

Answer 3

Michelle Stafford by a long shot.  I have been a long time viewer, and so I knew what Phyllis should act like and not act like, and I used to gag when Gina Tagnoni tried to play the part of Phyllis.  You could not even begin to compare the two actresses.  I know we all have our favorites and some may miss Gina, but as for me, I love the acting of Michelle Stafford.

Answer 4

Even though Gina Tognini did a good job of playing Phyllis, Michelle Stafford is better at it.

Answer 5

Michelle Stafford. Gina did an excellent job, it's just that Michelle had been in that role forever. I do miss the hot sex scenes between Nick and Phyllis now that the Covid has ruined it.